Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Who was in the wrong here? Plz advise.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Who was in the wrong here? Plz advise.

    Kindly take the time to read through this:

    My SO and I live oceans apart, in different continents. We had first "met" on another online community last year, and have been in a fantastic and loving relationship ever since. We've even had been lucky enough to meet once since then, and it was the most wonderful meeting.

    Ok this is what happened recently. He told me (while chatting) that he'd send me a gift by post. I told him not to bother, since I am not so big into material stuff and did not want him to take the trouble, but he really wanted to send me something and so I said sure! So anyway, a couple of days later he said he had put it in the mail and that it was on its way. And he told me that what he was sending was meant to be a special surprise for me. I was so excited, because it was to be my first gift from him and I love surprises and suspense. I wanted to discover for myself what it was.
    Anyway around then I happened to log into that other online forum that we're both members of (like I mentioned above) and was looking at the latest threads and blogs..... and I saw that in one of the threads he had posted a pic of that gift he was sending me (was a cute locket pendant) for our mutual "friends" and all other members on that forum to see! I saw many comments from them, including "Wow I wish I had a bf like you" etc. And I was really disappointed!! I was disappointed that he had to spoil my surprise before I even found out what it was, and had to PARADE it in front of others on that forum, most of whom were strangers whom we haven't even met!
    Anyway, I expressed my discontent to him during our subsequent chat. I asked him why he had to spoil my surprise and how much a surprise like that meant to me.... and that such things ought to be special and private, at least until it reaches the receiver. He totally refused to acknowledge that he did anything wrong..... and nor did he apologise. He was totally adamant, which is not like him at all!! He said he wanted to show off his love for me to other members of the forum, and that there's absolutely nothing wrong with what he did. A bit of an argument followed. We rarely ever have arguments!

    Now you all plz tell me, who was in the wrong here? Was I right to feel bad that he ruined that surprise? Or did I overreact? I may have! Do tell me honestly what you all think.

    #2
    I can see why you are dissapointed, of course. And it is something personal. My SO tends to prefer to keep things private between us.

    But I can also see why he wouldn't see it's a big deal. He cares about you so much that he wants to share it with everyone. I tend to be more like this (such as posting photos of us together on facebook).

    Basically, it's taken us some time and some issues like the one you describe above to figure out what we both expect and to think about the other person when we make decisions about how much we share with others.

    So, my basic answer is that neither of you are in the wrong!


    Comment


      #3
      I think this is a rather petty thing to have gotten in an argument about. It probably would have been a good idea for him to wait to post on a forum about it, if in the community the thread was about the gift he sent then you probably shouldn't have checked it. He was proud that he got a nice gift for you. Just let it go and enjoy the gift even if it didn't turn out to be a surprise. Just apologize for overreacting, it's a silly thing to get heated over.

      Comment


        #4
        Well I guess he should have asked me if I was ok with him posting it publicly. But I was surprised that he did though..... because even he's the type to keep matters between us very private. He probably was too excited. And another major catalyst for me heating up were the comments that others girls wrote, saying that they wish they had a bf like him etc.

        Btw ErinKristine, the thread wasn't specifically about his gift. It was more of a general thread, in which members post and share their latest purchases. I just happened to be checking it. And oh, of course I apologised

        I received the package today in the mail and was absolutely delighted, needless to say! He sent it with such love, after all. Made my day and week!

        I would like to get more inputs though, from other members. Would help me gain more clarity regarding the matter.
        Last edited by wondergirl; March 29, 2010, 09:53 PM.

        Comment


          #5
          I think he was in the wrong. I would have been upset too. I'm glad it came though and that you're happy!

          Comment


            #6
            I have to agree with you wondergirl, if he knew that both of you frequented that forum, then I think it was out of line to just post it on there. He specifically said it was a surprise, how could it be a surprise if he posted it up where you frequent for you to run across? It also seems to me like it was almost equally important to him that he got praise for giving a great present as it was that you enjoyed the gift.

            I know back in February, me and Garnet both waited until after Valentine's Day before we shared what we had gotten one another on the board here, because doing so beforehand would have spoiled the surprise. But like, in the VERY least, at least make you aware he was going to do such a thing, so you had the ability to avoid it or something? No, I don't think you were in the wrong at all here. I mean, if it was a misunderstanding and he apologized, I wouldn't think it's as big an issue, but yeah.

            Comment


              #7
              I think he was in the wrong. He should of waited until you recieved it. I would feel different if he had posted on something that you are not a part of, so you couldn't see it. But he knew good and well that you would be checking that forum..since you met there.

              I am glad he followed through and you got it. Sounds like a very nice gift, even if the suprise was ruined.

              Comment


                #8
                I'm personally terrible at keeping secrets.

                He was probably just as excited (maybe even more) for you to receive his gift. Waiting for the mail to deliver it can be agony. He probably wanted to let go of some of his excitement by sharing the news with people he thought would understand what it's like to be at the mercy of the snail-mail. Maybe he needed affirmation that his gift was going to make you feel as special as he wanted you to. I think it was an honest mistake and he didn't intend to upset you. I think the fact that he couldn't wait to share it is proof that this gift was more than just a simple gesture of love. Maybe you should try to think of his behavior as endearing. When my SO has little screw ups I just remind myself that this is one of the reasons why he is unique and how could I not love something that makes him him. Good luck with everything

                Comment


                  #9
                  Your boyfriend probably could have handled the situation better by not putting a picture of it on the forum you both use, but he probably just didn't think that you would see it. I can understand him wanting to share the surprise, and maybe next time he can tell you not to look at that specific thread. However, you really shouldn't give him a hard time about it in my opinion. You should be happy that he got you a wonderful present, not mad at him! He didn't have to get you anything! He might not want to do something like that again if he thinks that you will not appreciate it. Remember that it is the thought that counts, and he obviously cares about you! Think about it this way, you were surprised when you saw it on the forum, so it was still a surprise

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Of course it's the thought that counts and like I mentioned, I am delighted! I appreciate it alot and he knows that as well. In fact, I myself tell him not to bother sending anything coz I'm not that much into gifts and all.
                    We argued just once, but not a 2nd time.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Personally, I think you should have been thrilled that he loved you enough to INSIST on sending you a gift. Obviously he goofed on keeping the surprise, but that's hardly something worth getting worked up about. Honestly, I'm not surprised he wouldn't apologize. From his perspective he went through the trouble of buying and sending you a lovely gift and you found a way to criticize him! He was probably just excited and wanted to know if it was a good choice of gift!

                      I'm glad that you received it and have worked things out, though. Don't sweat the small stuff. Try and keep in mind that he was just trying to make you happy. And maybe if he tries to send you something again you should stay off the forum, just in case he lets it slip again

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I can understand your disappointment and agree with the others who said that he probably shouldn't have put it on somewhere where he knew you'd see it. In my opinion, it also depends on what kind of gift it is, though. If it's something really personal, I wouldn't want it on the internet at all. Luckily, my husband is not into publicly showing any of us and neither am I, really. I don't have pictures of us on this page and not on facebook either. My husband has pictures of us on facebook that are only visible to us and his sister/family. I go through phases when I want to show nice pictures of us online, to have people see that we're happy and show us off, but then I think it's quite vain of me to think that way and I like being anonymous on the web. It doesn't irk me so much that people can see the stuff, but thinking that some person I went to school with 10 years ago can download private pictures of my hubby and me is kinda disturbing...

                        Back on topic... I think there's no-one who's in the wrong here... he probably just wanted to get opinions on his gift and you overreacted as the surprise was gone. It was just an unlucky coincidence...

                        A similar thing happened when my husband got my anniversary gift... we had sent our gifts off on the same day, but somehow, mine made it to him faster than expected and I was still on spring break when he got it. Before we sent the packages off, we had agreed that we would open them together on webcam. So, I was at the airport when I called him and just from his "hello" I could tell that he was very happy. I asked him why he was in such a good mood and he said it was because he had gotten my gift today. I was like "you opened it without me?!?!?!?" - he had completely forgotten about our agreement because he was so excited when he got it. I was really hurt. Luckily, I had to board the plane and couldn't talk to him much more, because otherwise we might have ended up fighting. I just don't understand how he could have forgotten that, but then he sounded so happy when I talked to him that I couldn't stay mad at him. I just would've liked to see him open the package... oh, well. Things like that happen. With the postal service, you have to be glad if your SO even gets the stuff you send...
                        Last edited by lunamea; March 31, 2010, 06:13 PM.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          I would say that you overracted a bit, because we are all different and we all share our excitment in different ways. I hope it's working out good now!

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X